Impact of Process Management on Human Resources Development in Slovak Public Administration

Countries

Policy areas

Tags:
Capacity modellingDemand forecastEmploymentfinancial impactjob descriptionsProcess optimizationPublic administrationSallary gradetransparency

Organisation name Ministry of Interior of the Slovak Republic

Contact person: Luk‡_ Gablovsk_

lukas.gablovsky@minv.sk

Public administration: current stage

According to World Bank and European Commission the Slovak republic has one of the least developed public administration (PA), especially in the area of efficiency of PA, which proves the Worldwide Governance Indicators.

The OECD analysis ÒSlovak republic: Developing a Sustainable Strategic Framework for Public Administration ReformÓ (available at https://www.oecd.org/governance/slovak-republic-better-co-ordination-for-better-policies-services-and-results-9789264247635-en.htm) shows that PA in Slovak republic is characterized especially by non-quality and non-uniform system of human resource management and high turnover among staff. According to OECD review high turnover is caused by several factors including relatively unattractive work in PA as well as impact of the political cycle.

Organizations in PA and their processes are departmentally directed and vertically structured. It means, that besides core processes, organization units have to ensure  cross-sectional sub-processes like registry, managing assets, IT support, accounting etc., This is typical for traditional model of PA , which is still dependent on paper documents and files that are deposited in archives with limited capacity. Individualism of organizations is as well characterized by monolithic information systems with non-integrated data and registers, which is many times the cause of bottlenecks and inefficiencies.

According to the report INTERNATIONAL CIVIL SERVICE EFFECTIVENESS (INCISE) INDEX 2017 published by University of Oxford in 2017, Slovakia is ranked the least effective from 31 countries. The areas where performance is lower comparing to other countries are human resource management, digital services and policy making. (Reference document, page 1)

Employees in public administration

Data collected by the International Labour Organization suggest that employment in the Slovak Republic’s general government and public corporations (the Òpublic sectorÓ in the System of National Accounts) accounts for a relatively high share of total employment (27%; 2013) compared to other OECD countries, exceeded only by the Scandinavian countries (Denmark; 35%; 2013). A somewhat different picture emerges when employment in general government is separated out from employment in public corporations. Data for 2011 indicate that general government employment as a percentage of the labour force in the Slovak Republic was below the OECD average and very close to the Central and Eastern European country average.

Although the share of public administration employees in total employment is 27%, the problem is low wages. Compensation of government employees in the Slovak Republic as a percentage of GDP in 2010 was one of the lowest of all OECD countries (7.7% of GDP). In 2012, compensation of general government employees as a share of total public expenditure was below both the OECD and Central and Eastern European country average.

The salary system in Slovak public administration places importance on formal education and skills, but it less appreciates difficulty level of processes or individual performance. So far, there has been no systematic capacity planning executed or analysis published to ensure, that the government, as a whole, has an adequate workforce to deliver current or future strategic objectives in public service provision in an efficient and effective manner.

Operational programme Effective Public Administration 2014-2020

The above mentioned shortcomings were addressed in Strategic framework of Public administration reform  by defining strategic objectives, subsequently linked to Operational programme Effective Public Administration (OP EPA), launched by the Ministry of Interior of the Slovak republic (MI SR) in 2012These objectives, especially in area of performance and efficiency, are fulfilled through the national project ÒProcess Optimization in Public AdministrationÓ, funded by European Union funds. The project recognises the importance of stronger collaboration across institutional boundaries and seeks to rationalise the structure of the deconcentrated state administration, which is the biggest added value

Final results of using Process Management for Human Resources Development in Slovak Public Administration, which is a subset of national project, will contribute to robust whole-of-government coordination led by the centre of government, more systematic use of evidence-based policy making tools such as regulatory impact assessment, stronger decision making capacity to improve results, costs reduction, facilitate the daily work of the public administration and enhance the quality of services provided to citizens. In addition, a comprehensive human resources management reform provides opportunities to strengthen the quality and the performance of the central civil service in designing and delivering services effectively and efficiently to citizens.

When we talk about employees, the fair salary grade distribution and the definition of the necessary number of employees for each department in each district is the most important. Clear rules (transparency) will be reflected in reduced turnover, increased employee satisfaction and improved service quality.

The activity of the AMU will continue after the end of the project. The analysts are internal employees of the MI SR, which will be financed from the state budget. The project activities (know-how gained) will be repeated at regular annual intervals, mainly due to changing conditions (changes in legislation, human resources, new information technologies). The capacity model analysis will be implemented in other offices and ministries as well.

With this methodology we can assess the impact of legislation on the process in real time. This eliminates the unnecessary expenditures that will be used to fund relevant policies.

From the point of view of sustainability of process management and use of know-how, further progress within the reform is the increasing interest of top management in organizational-process audits, including personnel capacity and financial performance analysis. In addition to the outputs, awareness was raised not only about the methods of analysis, but also about the benefits that process management and analytics can accelerate.

Best practices

There were a number of workshops with PA employees, among which the process owners were clearly identified. The aim was to explain the project and make sure we are on the same page. In doing so, we eliminated the resistance to the proposed changes.

When implementing the project, the emphasis was on using a common language that was defined in the methodologies. Each of them is applicable separately, but when used together, they create a synergistic effect. The same approach is being applied at other ministries and that creates a wide business architecture of PA. The project includes continuous data collection and evaluation. These will be provided in a structured form and at regular basis to district office executives. Their task for the future is to plan and manage employees based on real data.

The use of our methodologies to calculate the capacity model can be applied at local, regional, national level and internationally as well. Our know-how will be used in inter-institutional cooperation. The MI SR has been approached by the Government Office (GO) and the Ministry of Finance for cooperation in the area of capacity model. The project is being launched at the GO and will continue at another 12 ministries.

Central components of procedural act (CCPA)

During mapping the processes in public administration we found out that majority of them are regulated by the same procedural act and performed almost identically. Therefore they have the potential to be automatized in the IT environment. Based on this fact, process templates were created and are available for authorities in PA. CCPA cover processes such as registration, archiving, delivery etc.

CCPA are valid for all ministries and other central government bodies that differ only in their specific agendas (e.g. education). The added value of CCPA is in the creation of IT systems. PA institutions do not have to create the entire IT systems, but only manage the specific parts, which might save costs.

Also interesting